الية تحكيم مسار البحث العلمى

The following criteria will be used to evaluate submissions:

I. Topic, Title, and Relevance (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • Does the title accurately reflect the main focus of the work?
  • Is the research problem or purpose clearly stated?
  • How significant is the problem/purpose? (Rate on a scale of [e.g., 1-5, 1-10])

 

II. Literature Review and Theoretical Framework (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • Does the literature review effectively demonstrate the relationships between variables?
  • Is the research situated within a clear theoretical/conceptual framework?
  • Does the problem statement identify gaps in existing knowledge?
  • Are references used appropriately and consistently in a recognized style to support the content?

 

III. Research Design and Methodology (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • What type of study design was employed? (e.g., Randomized controlled trial, Cohort study, Case-control study, etc.)
  • Is the study design appropriate given the research problem, theoretical framework, literature review, and hypotheses?
  • Are data collection procedures consistent across all subjects?
  • Were the rights and well-being of human subjects protected?
  • Was informed consent obtained from all subjects?
  • Are the methods clearly described and replicable?
  • Do the presented results align with the described methods?
  • Is the statistical analysis appropriate for the research question and study design?
  • Is a clear rationale provided for the selection of specific instruments or methods?
  • Is the chosen methodology coherent with the research problem and questions?
  • Are the results novel and do they contribute to advancements in the field?

 

IV. Presentation of Results (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • Are the descriptive and inferential statistics appropriate for the level of measurement of each variable?
  • Is the level of statistical significance reported?
  • Do the conclusions accurately reflect and summarize the presented data?

 

V. Impact and Applicability (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • Impact on the Saudi Healthcare System and Society: If implemented, would the research findings benefit the Saudi healthcare system, patients, or society? Describe the potential benefits.
  • Feasibility of Application: Is the direct application of the research findings feasible in terms of time, resources, financial costs, and legal/ethical considerations?
  • Adoption: Has the article/project been adopted by a healthcare institution or other relevant organization?

 

VI. Academic Impact and Significance (Weight: [Specify Weight if applicable])

  • Scientific and Clinical Significance:
  • If published, what is the anticipated profile of outputs (e.g., journal rankings, impact factor, Q1, Q2, Q3)?
  • Is the article/project likely to be well-received by peers in the researcher's discipline (e.g., based on reviews, journal stature, awards)?
  • Is the study replicable in other clinical settings?
  • Are the findings applicable to clinical practice?